• About me

Café culture addict

~ Drinking tea, observing society and writing stories in cafés

Café culture addict

Daily Archives: June 16, 2022

Luncheon on Grass

16 Thursday Jun 2022

Posted by Floreva in Life in style

≈ 10 Comments

I never liked this painting of Edouard Manet.

Because the women are naked or half naked while the men are fully clothed (with dark and quite heavy clothing, no less). And the foreground man seems to be pontificating. He’s wearing the hat of some students of the time.

As a woman, I felt it to be offensive. And I didn’t like, and still don’t, the display of patronizing way to, once more, assert a supposed superiority of male over female humans. So, pen being mightier than sword, here’s my countermeasure to this ongoing sexism.

It seems to me that the stark contrast shows how shocking it is, because it’s a seldom seen reverse of the “roles”. And it reveals how groomed we have been into thinking it’s ok to see a naked woman sitting between those two clothed men, with her female friend, half naked (or half dressed), knee deep in the pond behind them. Curious.(Original painting below).

This type of fantasist painting also reinforced in the collective consciousness the idea that it’s acceptable for women to be gallivanting in rivers in their undies or have luncheon naked.

Don’t get me wrong, I know it shocked people at the time, just as I was unimpressed when I first saw it. It brought fame to the painter as well as controversy, as Manet knew perfectly well how to use it ( look no further than his “Olympia”).

Art historians deemed this painting his most famous, because Manet brought nature into his painting to a perfect rendition. Ok, maybe. Probably here, fame (because of scandal) morphs into remarkable execution. Yet, I’m not convinced. I’d rather they were ALL naked…

And the fact that the woman breaks the “4th wall”, while unclothed could be read as an invitation for later… intimate games.

It also indicates a rule being broken by Manet.

It’s not a portrait, it’s a group painting. Looking at us, this young lady is showing she’s unashamed of her naked body (a good thing in my book), but in 1863, it could be read differently. And it sure sparked notoriety and controversy. The former because of the latter.

But still….

What kind of idea is that, if not another desire to portray women in a less than respectful way?

This is part of the so called “celebration of femininity” and beauty of the female body.

It’s just another lie to objectify women, evacuating their soul and personnality (and their consent maybe too?) of the equation and letting them know that they have nothing to say about it.

It’s also a trickster way to brainwash visitors into thinking that it’s the way things are and must be perpetuated.

This painting maybe a feat in terms of….. impressionist craft…. but it’s rubbish as to what message it aims at delivering and it’s time society stops celebrating art that devaluates this half of humankind.

Curiously, painting naked female body it ok. But painting or drawing naked male body and you’re bound to receive a warning, even be flagged as offensive and rated R. (hence the little club I had to put on the private parts of this gent for viewer sensitivity and to avoid to shock wordpress) .

As long as its not showing signs of … action… why should it be?

Why naked female body is ok and not male naked body? Why AGAIN a difference of treatment?

This society model is sickening.

But it’s changing, thank God(dess).

Share this:

  • Pinterest
  • Print
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Tumblr
  • P

Like this:

Like Loading...

Harvest timeline

June 2022
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  
« May   Jan »

Recentely brewed

  • Straw man. “I’m just a patsy”
  • Luncheon on Grass
  • Spell – Queen of Sheba
  • The Johnny Depp trial and why it matters
  • More guns with my breakfast, Hollywood, pls.

Flavours

#inkdrawing #Inktober #Inktober2018 #Inktoberday1 #inktoberday14 #Inktoberprompt #pencildrawing #ww1 Absolutely Fabulous Andrew Irvine Banana Republic Bette Davis book book signing Café Central characters Chocolate Cinema climate change Coffee Coronavirus creating Cumberbatch David Burland Poetry Prize Deep waters Demel Don Draper drawing entertainment Eve Fashion George Mallory George Sanders Gossip Girl Grace Kelly Happy Birthday hero Hofburg Hoffmann ink inkdrawing John Malkovich Johnny Cash Klimt Kolo Moser Life London Mad Men Marilyn Monroe Mount Everest movies music Our world Paris Poetry publishing pulmonary infection Raul Ruiz renegades Route 66 screenwriting Script Secession movement self-empowerment Sherlock short stories Sissi spell Steven Moffat submarine Tea Theatre Vienna Winter wonderland writing.

All rights reserved (photos, drawings, other media and text) – cafecultureaddict, copyright F.Vitel 2012-22 , Floreva and cafecultureaddict, unless otherwise stated

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Follow Following
    • Café culture addict
    • Join 112 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Café culture addict
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: